Pellet types: hardwood, blends and flavor woods
Start with one idea. Every grill pellet is made from wood, and the kind of wood is the thing that changes from bag to bag.
One wood or several?
A single-wood pellet comes from one type of tree. A blend mixes pellets or wood from more than one type. Wikipedia lists the wood varieties used: oak, maple, apple, alder, mesquite, cherry, hickory and pecan1.
Blends make more sense once you see a real one. One maker describes a competition blend as a mix of cherry, hickory and maple hardwoods2. The same maker's classic blend is pecan, hickory and mesquite2. Those are two blends, each built from three woods.
Quick check. If a bag says "apple" and nothing else, is it a blend? It isn't, going by the usual meaning. It names one wood. A bag naming three woods is a blend.
Why the wood matters
Wood changes the flavor. The type of wood used to make the pellets influences the final flavor of the food cooked on the grill3. Makers also pick their woods on purpose. One says certain hardwoods are chosen due to the flavor and aroma they produce when smoking2.
Makers like to describe each wood in a line or two. For example, one calls mesquite a strong aroma with a tangy and spicy flavor2. Another says hickory pellets work well with beef, chicken, pork and vegetables, and that apple pellets pair well with chicken or pork3.
Treat those lines as what each maker says about its own pellets. They aren't measurements, and taste is personal. You'll need to try a flavor yourself to know what you think of it.
What "hardwood" means on a label
Here's a term worth pinning down. Hardwood means wood from trees like oak, hickory and cherry. Softwood means wood from trees like pine. Grilling pellets are made from hardwood varieties, not softwood3.
So a label that says hardwood is a good start. It doesn't settle everything, though. A second word to look for is "100%". One maker says BBQ pellets are food-grade pellets made only from 100% hardwood4.
The label that matters most
Before you look at flavor, look for the word cooking. Always make sure to use pellets labeled as cooking pellets with your grill or smoker3. Cooking pellets are sometimes called BBQ, grilling or smoking pellets3. They're all the same family.
Heating pellets are a different family, made for stoves. For how they differ, read the page on food-grade and heating pellets.
What the sources don't tell you
Be careful with some claims you'll meet on bags and websites. The pages behind this one don't say how much of each wood is in a blend. They also don't say that one flavor is better than another, and neither does this page. If a bag lists percentages, those numbers come from the maker, and the maker's page is where to check them.
The sources also don't say that you need a certain wood for a certain grill. For that, your grill's manual is the one to trust. It may say which pellets the maker allows, or whether other brands are fine to use.
A simple way to think about it
Hold three ideas in order:
- The pellet is hardwood, pressed together. How that happens is on What grill pellets are made of.
- The wood or woods named on the bag set the flavor.
- A blend is just several woods in one bag.
Once you have those, labels get much easier to read. Wet pellets are a separate matter, and they're covered under Damp pellets: signs and what to do.
References
- Pellet grill, Wikipedia
- Wood Pellets for Smoking & Grilling, Pit Boss Grills
- How Are Grilling Pellets Made?, Bear Mountain BBQ
- Wood Pellet Misconceptions, Bear Mountain BBQ